Free Case Review Text us

Trial Pro P.A. is proud to advocate for accident victims all over the state of Florida, including from our Central Florida office in Orlando. Our dedicated experienced personal injury attorneys handle a range of legal matters, from employment disputes to auto accidents claims. We can use our knowledge and legal skills to help you not only achieve a favorable outcome but relieve the legal burden on your shoulders as well. Our entire team understands how challenging and confusing litigation can be, which is why we are here for you through every step of the process.

The Trial Pro, P.A. attorneys, carry more than a century of collective legal experience and decades of working together as a team. We have represented hundreds if not thousands of people who have been injured due to car accidents, slip-and-fall, worker's compensation cases, and more. One thing that is clear to us is the essence of partnership. Without it, Trial Pro, P.A. could not be as effective in attaining success for our clients.

What Does Res Ipsa Loquitur Mean?

Frequently Asked Questions - What Does Res Ipsa Loquitur Mean?

At the epicenter of personal injury cases lies the premise that the negligence of one caused damage to another.  However, just because you were a victim of an accident does not mean that your accident was caused by the negligence of someone else.  You will need to prove that the defendant negligently caused your injuries.  This is often quite simple to prove in auto accident cases.  However, in premise liability, product liability or medical malpractice cases, for instance, it may be more difficult to produce sufficient proof of negligence to substantiate the plaintiff’s injury claim.  Even though, you know for certain that the only logical explanation for the incident that caused your injuries is through the negligent behavior of another, quite often in those types of cases, direct evidence simply does not exist.  In such a scenario, you would invoke Res Ipsa Loquitur.  

When there is no direct evidence revealing negligence, there is a legal doctrine which allows you to use circumstantial evidence in order to establish negligence – Res Ipsa Loquitur – frequently shortened to Res Ipsa.  When translated, the Latin phrase, Res Ipsa Loquitur, merely means “the thing that speaks for itself”.  In legal terms however, the concept of Res Ipsa Loquitur is an evidentiary rule in tort law which permits the plaintiff (the injured party) to establish a presumption of negligence against the defendant (the at-fault party) through the use of circumstantial evidence.  Circumstantial evidence is the compilation of facts which point to negligence as the logical conclusion rather than demonstrating it outright with direct evidence.  Simply put, circumstantial evidence implies a fact based on other relevant information.  To quickly showcase the difference of direct and circumstantial evidence, let us use the example of a murder case – although this is criminal law and therefore not related to a premise liability case, it is simply a quick and easy way to differentiate direct and circumstantial evidence.  Direct evidence in that case would be videotaped footage of the murder or a confession from the murderer.  While circumstantial evidence would be eye-witness testimonies from individuals who saw the alleged murderer running from the murder scene covered in blood. 

Regarding tort law, in most states, there are three requirements that a plaintiff, or in most instances, their attorney, must first meet prior to a jury being allowed to make the inference that the defendant is negligent.  Those requirements are as follows:

  1. The incident would not normally occur unless someone acted negligently;
  2. The evidence confirms that neither the plaintiff nor a third party caused the injury or contributed to the injury; and
  3. The negligence in question falls within the scope of the defendant’s duty to the plaintiff.

As mentioned above, in order for Res Ipsa Loquitur to apply to an accident, there must be no contribution by that of the plaintiff, meaning this incident occurred to no fault of your own.  This doctrine also necessitates that the defendant has exclusive control and responsibility over the instrumentality or agent that caused the plaintiff’s injuries.   

If you are not quite familiar with legalese, this still may be slightly difficult to understand or follow.  Let us try using some real-life examples to showcase when it would be appropriate to utilize the principle of Res Ipsa Loquitur.  With premise liability, product liability or medical malpractice cases, at times you may find there is no direct evidence to indicate that another person was negligent in their behavior or lack thereof.  For example, if a surgeon left a foreign object inside of a patient – this would constitute an accident that ordinarily does not occur expect for failure to exercise due care.  In this circumstance, Res Ipsa Loquitur would be applicable and successful in a medical malpractice.  Or, say you decide to sue a vineyard for severe personal injuries sustained when a barrel of wine flew out of a window and hit you.  Although there is no direct evidence that the vineyard owner’s negligence caused your injuries, there is no other explanation as an incident of that magnitude does not usually occur unless someone acted negligently.  You did not cause your injuries by simply walking on their premises.  And, finally, the owner has a duty to ensure that wine barrels don’t fall out of their windows and strike the patrons.  Hence, this accident would meet the three elements of Res Ipsa Loquitur.  Another example wherein Res Ipsa Loquitur would be utilized would be if an e-cigarette exploded in your mouth.  The defendant, the e-cigarette company, would have exclusive control over the instrumentality of that device.  So, if their device suddenly exploded, it would mean there was negligence in the assembly or creation of that product.  And, if you were using the product exactly as directed in their product manual, then there would be no negligence placed on the plaintiff.  Therefore, this scenario would meet the requirement of Res Ipsa Loquitur as the accident would not have occurred if not for some type of negligence because the e-cigarette pens are not meant to explode, the plaintiff did not cause their own injury, and the negligence falls in the scope of the defendant as they created and sold a faulty and dangerous product which, in turn, caused severe personal injuries. 

Now, Res Ipsa Loquitur does not automatically ensure that you will win your case.  It is a way to argue negligence in your personal injury case.  However, if the defendant cannot rebut the presumption of negligence you established with Res Ipsa Loquitur, then the rule of Res Ipsa Loquitur will successfully stand, your case will prevail and you will be able to recover compensation. 

Whether you find the concept of Res Ipsa Loquitur simple or complex, it is always most prudent to consult the legal advice of an experienced attorney when attempting to pursue a personal injury case.  Their knowledge and understanding of all legal doctrines and case law and their applications of such in court are vital.  Every personal injury accident is different – even two slip and fall cases can vary drastically.  An experienced personal injury attorney will ensure that you receive the best legal representation for your injuries and receive the compensation you deserve. 

Free Case Review Text us
Personal Injury Attorneys
Committed to Your Personal & Financial Recovery

Our goal is to make the process as easy as possible for you. You don't even have to come into our office if you cannot travel or adjust your schedule to make it to us. We're more than happy to come to you!

In addition to traveling directly to our clients, the team at Trial Pro, P.A. also pledges to provide clear advice and regular client communication. We know how vital regular contact with our clients is - we never leave you hanging or delay our responses. 

Orlando Personal Injury Attorneys
After experiencing an automobile accident, the last thing you desire is to have an attorney at hand that doesn’t know how to represent you adequately. You want a reputable law firm that will.
Personal Injury Attorneys
Serious Representation
We put our knowledge and legal abilities into action to assist you to attain a positive outcome and ease the legal stress from your shoulders simultaneously. Trial Pro, P.A., holds a reputation for achieving real success for clients. Please leave it to us to fight wisely but aggressively. 
Personal Injury Lawyer
Unmatched Case Results
Experiencing a car accident can be frustrating and scary, but our promises to you are fully authentic. Trial Pro, P.A.'s injury legal attorneys, do not under-deliver. Instead, we do everything in our capabilities to go above and beyond your expectations. 
Car Accident Lawyers
Committed to Our Clients
It would help if you didn't have to beg for a call back from your attorney. It would be best if you didn't have to beg for an update on your case. At Trial Pro, P.A., we don't operate in that manner. We constantly call our clients to give them updates on their claims. If we miss a call, we promise always to return it.
Orlando Car Accident Lawyer
Compassionate In & Out of Court
Our objective is to enable our clients to relax and concentrate on healing, recognizing that the legal professionals at Trial Pro, P.A. holds the knowledge and resources to adequately tackle all the legal and financial specifics associated with their dispute.
Pursuing Client Victories

Based in Florida, Trial Pro, P.A. represents clients across Florida from our offices in Miami, Orlando, Ft. Myers, Naples, Delray Beach, Jacksonville, and Daytona Beach. We are dedicated to fully serving you to every degree. We vow to make the entire process of working with us as easy and as stress-free as possible. Therefore, we are more than happy to meet with you at your home, place of employment, hospital room, or other business that you find more convenient. You are always welcome to come into our office as well.

Free Case Review Text us

 Send Message
* The following info is required
 Our Locations
Trial Pro P.A. is proud to advocate for accident victims all over the state of Florida. Our dedicated, experienced personal injury attorneys handle various legal matters, from employment disputes to auto accidents claims. We can use our knowledge and legal skills to help you not only achieve a favorable outcome but relieve the legal burden on your shoulders as well. Our entire team understands how challenging and confusing litigation can be, which is why we are here for you through every step of the process.

Trial Pro P.A. Orlando Office

  (407) 300-0000

 250 N Orange Ave 14th Floor
Orlando, FL 32801

Trial Pro P.A. Tampa Office

  (813) 522-5444

 1000 N. Ashley Drive, Suite 512
Tampa, FL, 33602

Trial Pro P.A. Naples Office

  (239) 300-0000

 870 111th Ave N #1
Naples, FL 34108

Trial Pro P.A. Fort Myers Office

  (239) 400-5000

 9341 Marketplace Rd
Fort Myers, FL 33912

Trial Pro P.A. Melbourne Office

  (321) 586-2088

 2551 W. Eau Gallie Blvd., Suite 102
Melbourne, FL, 32935

Contact Info
250 N Orange Ave, 14th Floor
Orlando, FL 32801
(407) 300-0000

Our law firm fights aggressively -- always determined to win your case. 

Trial Pro, P.A. Car Accident Attorneys
Trial Pro, P.A.

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. The Information presented at this site should not be construed as formal legal advice nor the formation of an attorney-client relationship. For medical advice and treatment, you should contact a licensed medical professional.